Rust diseases are on the rise

In the past few years many “new” rust pathogens have found their way into the United States, including daylily rust. In 2005, guava rust (Puccinia psidii) exploded in San Diego County, Calif., on field-grown myrtle, and it happened again last year. As the name indicates, it was originally found on guava but it attacks many other members of the Myrtaceae family. During the same time frame, guava rust also appeared for the first time on some tropical crops in Hawaii. This disease has caused serious losses in the eucalyptus industry in many countries, including Brazil.

{sidebar id=55}

Probably the worst new rust is gladiolus rust (Uromyces transversalis). This disease was quarantined, but in the spring-summer 2006 a very severe outbreak was found in Florida gladiolus production. The same disease was found in a very small commercial cut flower operation in San Diego County. It has not been found in operations of major cut gladiolus producers in other U.S. locations.

Every year, white rust on chrysanthemum (Puccinia horiana P. Henn.) has been encountered at ports of entry. Once in a while it has been found in production greenhouses, especially in the Northeast and along the West Coast. Last year was no exception, with cases reported in the Northeast.

Soybean rust (Phakopsora pachyrhizi), which is a quarantined disease, has finally entered the United States. It is the focus of quite a bit of attention from federal and local officials.

Chemical control of rusts

Researchers at Chase Research Gardens have been studying rust diseases and have found that these fungi do not always cooperate. We did finish three trials on hypericum rust (Uromyces triquetrus) once we discovered that one cultivar was particularly susceptible while many others were virtually immune. Over the past 10 years, we have worked on a variety of rusts including geranium, snapdragon, bellis (English daisy), solidago, rose and hypericum. Most of the results were consistent from crop to crop so some broad conclusions can be made.

In the first trial, products were applied as a foliar spray three times on a seven-day interval. The best control of rust in this trial (see Table 1) was achieved with the 6-ounce rate of Armada (an experimental product combining triadimefon and trifloxystrobin) or Heritage (azoxystrobin). Vitavax (oxycarboxin) provided very good control but caused severe stunting. This fungicide is labeled for seed treatment, but was trialed since Plantvax, a related compound, was so successful against rusts in the past. Some of the sterol inhibitors also caused significant stunting (triadimefon in Armada and Terraguard 50WP).

Effect of fungicides on prevention of hypericum rust and plant stunting

Chemical

Rate per 100 gallons of water

Rust control

Stunting

Concert

16 ounces

Good

None

Armada

3 ounces

Very good

Slight

Armada

6 ounces

Excellent

Moderate

Eagle 40 WSP (Systhane)

8 ounces

Good

None

Heritage

4 ounces

Excellent

None

Terraguard 4SC

8 ounces

Good

None

Terraguard 50 WP

8 ounces

Good

Moderate

Vitavax

4 ounces

Very good

Severe

In a second trial, fungicides were applied weekly four times. This trial was performed on plants with hypericum rust and eradication was attempted. The results (see Table 2) show just how hard it can be to eradicate some rust diseases once they start to infect the plant. Even inclusion of wetting agents (i.e., Sync and Latron B) did not result in a high degree of eradication. Clevis is a combination of mancozeb and myclobutanil, which are each very good in preventing rust. Efficacy was only slight for some and was better when applied on a seven-day interval instead of a 14-day interval. The best control was seen with Heritage plus Latron B, but even in this case, eradication was only moderate.

Effect of fungicides on eradication of hypericum rust

Chemical

Rate/100 gallons, treatment interval

Degree of eradication

Clevis

16 ounces, 7 days

Some

Clevis and Sync

16 ounces each, 7 days

Some

Clevis

16 ounces, 14 days

Slight

Clevis and Sync

16 ounces each, 14 days

Slight

Phyton 27

25 ounces, 7 days

Some

ZeroTol

1.0% once, then 0.33% (7 days)

None

Heritage and Latron B

2 ounces each, 7 days

Moderate

The final test on hypericum rust was performed as a preventive trial with three applications at a 14-day interval (see Table 3). The disease did not develop extensively in this trial, but the best control was seen with Eagle at 3 ounces per 100 gallons and the combination of Insignia and Capsil (both rates). Under higher disease pressure, a seven-day interval would likely be required.

Effect of fungicides as a preventive treatment of hypericum rust

Chemical

Rate per 100 gallons

Rust control

Compass O

2 ounces

Good

Capsil

2 ounces

Some

Eagle 40 WSP

3 ounces

Very good

Insignia

4 ounces

Good

Insignia and Capsil

4 ounces and 2 ounces

Very good

Insignia

8 ounces

Some

Insignia and Capsil

8 ounces and 2 ounces

Very good

Best rust control options

Growers are still relying on protectant products available in the 1970s such as chlorothalonil and mancozeb for prevention of rust. Newer, systemic fungicides like sterol inhibitors (propiconazole, myclobutanil and triadimefon), as well as strobilurins (azoxystrobin, kresoxim methyl, pyraclostrobin and trifloxystrobin) provide some eradicant benefits.

The three trials conducted on hypericum rust indicate that many of the new combination fungicides will be beneficial for rust control. However, it is important to realize that many are based on the same chemical groups that had previously been identified as the best for rust control.

Use a 14- to 21-day application interval with protectants like mancozeb when conditions are unfavorable for rust and you are in a preventive mode. If an outbreak occurs, application of sterol inhibitors and strobilurins with a wetting agent will be your most effective means of eradication. Be sure to rotate between classes of fungicides or tank mix a protectant and systemic eradicant to make sure resistance does not develop.

{sidebar id=1}

- Ann Chase